Natalie Schafer
Actor · 26 credits · 15 in highly-rated films
Best known for Anastasia (1956)
Frequent collaborators: Jim Backus, Alan Hale Jr.
Best Natalie Schafer movies by genre
Movies (26 total, ranked by score)
1Anastasia
1956 · ★ 6.8 (191 votes)
Drama, Romance
2Caught
1949 · ★ 6.6 (99 votes)
Drama, Romance, Thriller
3Wonder Man
1945 · ★ 6.6 (44 votes)
Comedy, Fantasy, Music
440 Carats
1973 · ★ 5.7 (19 votes)
Comedy, Romance
5The Other Love
1947 · ★ 6.0 (17 votes)
Drama, Romance
6Back Street
1961 · ★ 5.6 (18 votes)
Drama, Romance
7Just Across the Street
1952
Comedy
8Marriage Is a Private Affair
1944 · ★ 7.1 (5 votes)
Mystery, Romance, War
9The Castaways on Gilligan's Island
1979 · ★ 6.6 (10 votes)
TV Movie, Comedy
10Forever, Darling
1956 · ★ 6.9 (10 votes)
Comedy, Romance
11The Petrified Forest
1955 · ★ 6.8 (4 votes)
Drama, TV Movie
12Callaway Went Thataway
1951 · ★ 5.6 (16 votes)
Comedy, Western
13The Girl Next Door
1953 · ★ 4.0 (3 votes)
Comedy, Music, Romance
14Take Care of My Little Girl
1951 · ★ 5.3 (14 votes)
Drama
15The Poor Fish
1930
16Molly and Me
1945 · ★ 6.4 (12 votes)
Comedy
17Female on the Beach
1955 · ★ 5.7 (35 votes)
Drama, Crime, Thriller
18The Law and the Lady
1951 · ★ 6.4 (7 votes)
Comedy
19Beverly Hills Brats
1989 · ★ 5.0 (12 votes)
Comedy
- 20
The Canterville Ghost
1966 · ★ 9.0 (1 votes)
Comedy, Drama, Music
21Oh, Men! Oh, Women!
1957 · ★ 5.8 (2 votes)
Comedy
22The Harlem Globetrotters on Gilligan's Island
1981 · ★ 5.4 (8 votes)
Comedy, Family, TV Movie
23I'm Dangerous Tonight
1990 · ★ 4.9 (29 votes)
Horror, Thriller, TV Movie
24Masquerade in Mexico
1945 · ★ 5.4 (5 votes)
Comedy, Music
25Rescue from Gilligan's Island
1978 · ★ 4.5 (32 votes)
Comedy, Adventure, TV Movie
26If You Knew Elizabeth
1957
TV Movie, Comedy, Drama
Credits are ranked using the same weighted score as movie collections. Last updated Aug 30, 2026.